Thursday, June 10, 2010

"Dwindling" Whites

*Disclaimer* I am not a demographer. I am a linguist. Yet, I do pretty ok with quantitative data, and visual display thereof. Therefore, I feel at least equally qualified as the AOL News Contributor who reported "White Population Dwindling as Calif. Grows."

Apparently there has been a trend for White Californians to move out of the state. The important bit of data:
[W]hites accounted for just under 41 percent of California's overall population in 2008, down from 47 percent in 2000.


The article also includes 3D pie charts representing the demographic breakdown of California in 2000 and 2008. These pie charts are object lessons in why you should never use pie charts. Go to the article, look at the pie charts. Now, without cheating (the data is displayed when you hover your mouse over), which group grew more, Asians or Blacks?

The article also links to the California Department of Finance report, which contains the raw data. I've downloaded this data, and carried out my own graphical analysis of it.

Figure 1


Oh the poor dwindling Whites!

A stacked bar chart is also illuminating.

Figure 2



So, there's been a decrease in the size of the White population, but Whites are still the plurality of the state. Does this constitute a dwindling? I'm not much of a semanticist, so I'll just leave that point there.

So what's the big story here? I see two. First is the large increase in size of the Hispanic population. It's clear from Figure 1 that they are on track to become the plurality population in the state. The second is the increase of the Multiracial category. Figure 3 plots the %Annual Change within each group.

Figure 3


While Hispanics, Asians, and Pacific Islanders have been showing an average 3% annual increase in population size, the Multiracial group has been increasing by 6% annually.

Overlooking the big story in the data, overblowing a smaller effect, and producing that god awful pie chart are all symptoms of the same disease, I believe. It's what happens when you have a story, or an analysis first, then look at the data.

Tuesday, May 25, 2010

Blogging Again

I'm just returning from the annual NSF IGERT Project Meeting. I've been supported by an NSF IGERT fellowship during my first two years of graduate school, and was asked to present a poster on my research. Mine was on a dialect geography project I did on the low-back merger and subsequent changes, specifically TRAP retraction and STRUT lowering. I didn't win the poster prize in my research category, but another linguist working in second language acquisition did! Congrats Sunyoung!

I've decided to resurrect this blog after the Digital Science panel discussion. Blogging about my field seems like a fine way to spend my (little) free time. My only apprehension is that I'm blogging openly under my real name. I'm sure everyone in academia has the experience of coming across a paper they wrote in undergrad or early graduate school, and felt a little ashamed and embarrassed by it. Now I'm planning to archive that on the open internet? I've got to be a little crazy.

But, I'm also very passionate, and we all need to fail a lot before finding success. So here goes nothing!

Thursday, August 20, 2009

This is a blog readable post

My university is installing and testing a new, campus wide alarm system, which they are calling the Siren Outdoor System (SOS). Is it overkill? The whole campus and surrounding areas are already under constantant video surveilance, and they have a pretty good emergency texting program. I don't know what this says about the student body (or more importantly, their parents) if they can't feel safe with out a giant alarm system safety net, but if the university has got the time and money to burn, god bless. That's not the point of my post.

To quote one of the notification e-mails about the system:
The purpose of the SOS is to transmit voice intelligible emergency messages and alert tones to the outdoor campus environment during crisis events.

I do believe that a "voice intelligible" emergency message is one which is intelligible to voices. At best, it might be a message which is intelligible as a voice. I don't think it can really mean what they want it to mean: an intelligible voice emergency message. See: "human readable".

Perhaps I'm suffering from a bracketing error, and they mean it's a

[ voice [ intelligible [ emergency message ] ] ]

but based on the rest of the e-mail, it seems pretty clear that they mean it's a

[ [voice [intelligible] ] [ emergency message] ]

It just can't mean what they want it to mean.

Disqus for Val Systems